Police Shut Down Breath Test Machines!

Posted by Matt Olszewski on February 23, 2011

If you are accused of DUI in the State of Florida, a breath test result is a legal presumption of guilt; if you charged with driving with a breath-alcohol content of .08% or higher, the machine is the only evidence of breath-alcohol.  Either way you look at it, will be facing a “trial by machine”.

Are these machines good enough to prove guilt or innocence beyond a reasonable doubt? To turn citizens into criminals? The Attorney General in Washington D.C. doesn’t think so…and the machines used in D.C. are made by the same manufacturer as the machines used in Florida! Do you think that the breath test machines in D.C. are the only ones giving inaccurate and false results?

D.C. Attorney General Drops Drunk Driving Cases

Wash. DC.  Feb. 8 — The District’s attorney general has dropped dozens of drunken driving cases since Jan. 31 and hundreds of others could be dropped as the police department shuts down its troubled alcohol breath-test program. Problems dating back more than three years with the city’s breath analyzers were first revealed in February 2010, when it was discovered the machines’ results were inaccurate. Since then, the D.C. medical examiner’s office has refused to sign off on the accuracy tests of new analysis machines, officials said.

“The alcohol breath-analysis program? It doesn’t exist anymore,” said Ilmar Paegle, who discovered problems with the Intoxilyzer 5000s soon after he took over the city’s breath-analysis program on Feb. 1, 2010. Paegle’s contract ended last week. As he left, he said, the police department pulled off the street the Intoximeter, which replaced the Intoxilyzer last spring. “It’s a royal mess,” Paegle said.

A spokeswoman for D.C. Attorney General Irvin Nathan said he couldn’t be pulled from a meeting to comment Tuesday. Nathan dropped eight more drunken driving cases Tuesday.

City policy requires the medical examiner’s office to certify the program, and it has not done so, citing concerns raised by the problems with the previous models, Paegle said. Although officers had been using the Intoximeters, the results were not being included as evidence, according to Paegle and internal police e-mails obtained by The Washington Examiner.

The medical examiner’s office declined to comment, citing pending litigation. Dozens of defendants have sued the city after being convicted on potentially faulty breath-test results.

Assistant police Chief Patrick Burke said officers are now taking urine samples to test blood alcohol levels for potential future prosecutions.

Meanwhile, the two police officers who account for a third of the city’s 1,400 annual drunken driving arrests have had their trial testimony called into question. They are the subjects of an internal affairs investigation that began after they spoke out about problems with the breath analyzers.

Officers Jose Rodriguez and Andrew Zabavsky learned that the medical examiner hadn’t signed off on the program and began mentioning that in their trial testimony last spring, according to an e-mail from Zabavsky to police Chief Cathy Lanier. Later in the spring, the attorney general’s office began an investigation into the officers, saying a woman they arrested for driving under the influence in June 2009 had complained the two watched her take a urine test.

In December, the case was turned over to internal affairs.

“On a day-by-day basis, cases are being dismissed because the officers involved are being investigated,” said defense lawyer Bryan Brown.

The result, police union chief Kris Baumann said, is “our ability to enforce DUI laws in the District has been crippled”.


No DUI arrest is perfect. Law Enforcement officers are human. They make mistakes. Breath Test Operators are human. They also make mistakes. Breath Test Inspectors are human. They too can make mistakes. The breath test machine isn’t perfect. It often makes mistakes and in some circumstances can be flat out wrong. The FL DUI Group knows DUI cases. The FL DUI Group knows the mistakes that occur in DUI cases and we will expose those mistakes to the judge and jury. Let our truly unique experience work for you. Your case deserves dedicated DUI defense. It’s what we do. If you have been arrested for DUI, contact the FL DUI Group today to schedule your free case evaluation.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Q. May I refuse to take a breath, blood or urine test if requested to submit to one by a DUI law enforcement officer in Orlando, Central Florida or West Palm Beach?
A. If lawfully arrested for DUI, by accepting the privilege extended by the laws of this state of operating a motor vehicle, you are deemed to have given your consent to submit to a breath test and/or urine test. However, y [ ... ]
Name*
Phone*
Email*
Case Description*
Arrested for DUI? You have 10 days to fight to keep your driver’s license. The FL DUI Group offers Free Consultations and will thoroughly review your case at no obligation to you. We are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. To contact us TODAY, please call (321) 256-1141
or toll free at (855) MY-FL-DUI